Many people will be talking about Marlisa's win on The X Factor last night, and therefore I will. I had a beef, and have that very same beef with young contestants on these types of shows. Marlisa is undoubtedly a good singer, and developed during the course of the show into a fine performer, and I am happy for her and her family, (and for Ronan who finally cracked a win after 5 years) but...
Marlisa's age was constantly referred to during the competition which gave her an unfair advantage over the other contestants. It was used to excuse poor performances and to garner sympathy. Secondly, this young lady clearly struggled more than others with the emotional strain of being on The X Factor. It may only be a television show but the contestants work very hard, and are under a lot of pressure and public scrutiny. I don't think children should be subjected to such stress. Thirdly, I felt uncomfortable watching Marlisa: dressing beyond her years, and singing songs with which she could not possibly have had any emotional connection.
I wish her well, and I am happy for her success, but...
Any thoughts on young contestants on TV shows?
The X Factor in the UK is just starting it's live shows. Young contestants are usually praised when they have done well and when they haven't, acknowledged that they have done well to be where they are considering their age. I have never seen a young contestant win in the UK because of this though, if they can't cut it then they usually end up going at some point.
ReplyDelete